Stratechery在21号的更新中放了一份设计师读者的来信,探讨关于Figma的问题,对我颇有启发,取了其中部分内容机翻一下分享给大家。以下为读者来信的前两段,机翻结果来自DeepL:
A note of great unimportance to your Figma beats Photoshop newsletter is that when we were all using Photoshop, we only designed for 1 screen size. For web it was something like 1200 wide by whatever. For mobile it was 320 x 480. Now, in addition to all the people and sharing on teams, we have to make Android, iPhone mini, iPhone huge, iPad, AppleTV, Watch, responsive mobile web → desktop web, etc etc. The tool has to change, because the problem changed. But Photoshop can’t change, cuz so many people rely on it to do, ya know, photo type tasks.
对您的Figma beats Photoshop通讯来说,一个非常不重要的说明是,当我们都在使用Photoshop时,我们只为一种屏幕尺寸进行设计。对于网页来说,它是类似于1200宽的东西。对于手机,它是320 x 480。现在,除了所有的人和团队的分享,我们还得做安卓、iPhone mini、iPhone huge、iPad、AppleTV、Watch、响应式移动网络→桌面网络,等等等等。工具必须改变,因为问题变了。但Photoshop不能改变,因为有那么多人依赖它来做,你知道,照片类型的任务。
Figma’s other great paradigm advancement over Photoshop is that the canvas is expansive and open (just like Illustrator), whereas Photoshop keeps everything constrained to a single page. Photoshop tried to add multiple art boards as it saw people jumping to Sketch, but it’s a hack, and your document slows and slows as you add more, because on the back side, you’re actually making a 30,000px wide document that gets displayed as lots of tiny screens. Figma’s expansive page makes it so much easier to write notes in the margin, annotate artboards with task lists and tags, gather sticky notes in messy piles, and anything else that make the GUI desktop better than the command line. It lets you keep more of the work closer to your project. In the past, I’d have folders of notes, pictures, PSDs, videos. Now all that file organization takes place inside a Figma canvas. The notes and documentation can follow the work, instead of being tangental to it, and accidentally separated from it.
与Photoshop相比,Figma的另一个巨大的范式进步是,画布是扩展的、开放的(就像Illustrator一样),而Photoshop则把一切都限制在一个页面上。当Photoshop看到人们跳到Sketch时,它试图增加多个艺术板,但这是一个Hack,当你增加更多的时候,你的文档就会越来越慢,因为在背面,你实际上是在制作一个30000px宽的文档,被显示为很多小屏幕。Figma 的宽广页面让你更容易在空白处写下笔记,用任务列表和标签来注释艺术板,把粘性纸条乱七八糟地堆在一起,以及其他任何让 GUI 桌面优于命令行的东西。它让你把更多的工作放在你的项目附近。在过去,我有笔记、图片、PSD、视频的文件夹。现在,所有这些文件的组织都在 Figma 画布中进行。笔记和文件可以跟在工作后面,而不是与工作相联系,并意外地与工作分开。